How to Compare Multiple Gold Buyers
Jul 26, 2023
{
"Title": "How to Compare Gold Buyers and Get the Best Offer Safely",
"Date": "07/26/23",
"Content": "
Practical Guidance for Anyone With Unwanted Gold, Silver, or Coins
\n\n
When you have gold jewelry, dental gold, sterling silver flatware, or old coins you no longer want, one of the biggest decisions is choosing where to sell. Not all gold buyers pay the same. Some may make their fees clear, others may not. By understanding how to identify your metals, weigh them properly, and keep good records, you can compare offers fairly and avoid common mistakes.
\n\n
Step 1: Identify What You Have
\n
Before comparing gold buyers, you need to know exactly what’s in your collection:
\n
\n
Karat markings for gold: Look for stamps like 10K, 14K, 18K, 22K, or 24K. These numbers show how much pure gold is in the piece. For example, 14K gold is about 58% pure.
\n
Silver hallmarks: Common marks include “925,” “Ster,” or “Sterling.” Anything marked EPNS, SP, or “plated” is mostly base metal with a thin silver layer.
\n
Dental gold: Crowns and bridges are often 16K–22K but are usually alloyed with other metals for strength. Small amounts of porcelain or steel are common.
\n
Coins: U.S. dimes, quarters, and half-dollars minted before 1965 usually contain 90% silver. Reference tables are available from the U.S. Mint.
\n
\n\n
Step 2: Confirm Authenticity
\n
Buyers will perform their own tests, but you can do basic checks:
\n
\n
Magnet test: Real gold and sterling silver are not magnetic. If a strong magnet pulls the piece, it’s likely plated.
\n
Visual inspection: Look for worn spots, flaking, or areas where a different color shows through—these may indicate plating.
\n
Acid and electronic testers: Consumer-friendly kits exist for basic home testing. For peace of mind, many sellers rely on professional testing with calibrated tools.
\n
\n\n
Step 3: Weigh Your Metals
\n
Use a digital pocket scale that measures grams. Why grams? Nearly all gold and silver buyers will base offers on weight in grams, multiplied by the daily market price and adjusted for purity. Remember:
\n
\n
Weigh gold of different karats separately (e.g., keep 10K and 14K in different bags).
\n
Keep tiny scraps, clasps, or dental fragments together—small items add up.
\n
Expect that stones and non-metal parts do not add to the payout.
\n
\n\n
Step 4: Understand Melt Value vs. Offer Value
\n
Buyers typically pay based on melt value—the worth of pure metal once refined. Keep in mind:
\n\n \n \n \n \n
Term | Meaning | Impact |
|---|---|---|
Melt Value | Value of pure gold or silver once refined, based on market prices. | Maximum potential worth of your item. |
Resale Value | Extra value if jewelry could be resold intact. | Some pieces (designer or antique) may bring more if resellable. |
Payout / Offer | What the buyer actually pays you after fees and margins. | This is what you should compare across buyers. |
\n\n
Step 5: Organize for Fair Comparison
\n
To prevent confusion between multiple offers, keep clear notes:
\n
\n
Record weights by karat or metal type.
\n
Write down any known hallmarks or unique details.
\n
Use simple spreadsheets or inventory tools to log items and offers. One example is GavelBase, which lets individuals organize collections and records.
\n
Photograph each group of items before mailing.
\n
\n\n
Step 6: Packing and Mailing Safely
\n
When you are ready to get tested offers or quotes by mail, follow best practices:
\n
\n
Remove non-metal parts when safe to do so, such as stones or beads that won’t add value.
\n
Separate items by karat or type into small clear bags, then seal them in one padded envelope.
\n
Always use tracked and insured shipping. USPS Registered Mail and Insurance offers strong protection. FedEx or UPS insured options are also common choices.
\n
Keep copies of your shipping label and tracking number.
\n
\n\n
Step 7: Expect Transparent Testing
\n
Reputable buyers will explain their testing methods clearly. Common expectations include:
\n
\n
Visual confirmation of hallmarks under magnification.
\n
Non-destructive electronic or acid spot testing to confirm karat.
\n
Clear results summary, often available online or sent with your quote.
\n
\n
Some companies, such as International Gold & Silver, provide a simple online quote form before you ship and then deliver detailed breakdowns after testing, so you can decide whether to accept or decline the final offer.
\n\n
Step 8: Payment Options and What to Know
\n
Once you accept an offer, payment can arrive by different methods:
\n
\n
PayPal: Fast, widely used; fees may apply for instant transfers.
\n
Venmo or Cash App: Convenient for smaller amounts; some limits exist on transfer size.
\n
Zelle: Often near-instant to linked bank accounts, but daily caps can apply.
\n
ACH / Direct Deposit: Secure for larger sums; may take 1–2 business days.
\n
Check: Traditional paper option; slower, but good for those avoiding digital transfers.
\n
\n\n
Step 9: Compare Offers Objectively
\n
When you receive offers back from multiple buyers, focus on real numbers:
\n
\n
Compare weight and karat categories; make sure they are consistent.
\n
Check for any shipping or service fees that reduce your payout.
\n
Don’t be swayed by hype or temporary bonuses—look at the net amount you will receive.
\n
\n\n
Quick Checklist
\n
\n
✔ Identify and separate by karat or silver purity
\n
✔ Weigh each group in grams
\n
✔ Photograph and record details
\n
✔ Package securely with insured shipping
\n
✔ Keep tracking and copies of notes
\n
✔ Review clear testing results
\n
✔ Compare actual payouts after fees
\n
\n\n
FAQs
\n
How do I know if gold is real? Look for karat stamps, try a magnet, and consider professional testing. True gold is non-magnetic and often stamped with a karat number like 14K.
\n
What about dental gold? Clean pieces carefully, keep all fragments together, and expect mixed alloys. Most buyers accept it once tested.
\n
What if my coins are collectible? Some coins may fetch more from collectors than melt value. Research rare dates through trustworthy resources like the U.S. Mint.
\n
Is mailing gold safe? Yes, if you use tracked and insured shipping methods with documented packing. Always take photos before sealing.
\n\n
Conclusion
\n
Comparing gold buyers is much easier when you organize upfront. By identifying items, confirming purity, weighing accurately, and documenting everything, you can evaluate offers side by side. Use notes, photos, and spreadsheets to stay consistent. Ultimately