Will Stones Add Value When Selling Jewelry
Jul 9, 2023
{
"Title": "Do Stones Add Value When Selling Jewelry? What to Know Before You Sell Gold and Silver Items",
"Date": "07/09/23",
"Content": "
Understanding What Really Adds Value When Selling Jewelry
\n\n
When people decide to sell old or unwanted jewelry, one of the most common questions is whether gemstones or decorative stones will increase the payout. This is a practical concern, especially for everyday jewelry that may include small diamonds, synthetic stones, or decorative accents. The reality is that in most resale situations, stones do not contribute significant value. Buyers typically focus on the actual gold, silver, or platinum content because that is the objective material with measurable worth. Understanding this distinction will help you prepare and set realistic expectations before mailing in or bringing in items.
\n\n
Step 1: Identify the Precious Metal Content
\n
Most jewelry value comes from the metal itself rather than stones. Here’s how to start:
\n
\n
Look for karat stamps such as 10K, 14K, 18K, 22K, or 24K on gold pieces. These tell you the gold purity.
\n
Check for silver hallmarks like 925, sterling, or “ster.” indicating sterling silver (92.5% pure).
\n
Test the metal if unsure. Simple methods include the magnet test (precious metals are non-magnetic), an acid test kit, or an electronic tester.
\n
Use a magnifier to closely inspect small engravings or hallmarks, especially on clasps and inner bands.
\n
\n
For additional reference, the U.S. Mint coin composition charts can help you identify silver content in older coins.
\n\n
Step 2: Understand the Role of Stones
\n
While stones can be beautiful, their role in resale is limited. Here’s what you need to know:
\n
\n
Small accent stones (tiny diamonds, chips, or synthetics) rarely add resale value because removal and sorting costs exceed potential worth.
\n
Common decorative stones like cubic zirconia, glass, or crystals typically have no resale market value.
\n
Gem-quality stones (certified diamonds, sapphires, emeralds, rubies) may hold separate value if they are large, verifiable, and of high quality—but verifying takes expertise.
\n
Laboratory-grown stones are increasingly common and usually valued less than natural stones on the resale market.
\n
\n
In short: unless you know you have a high-quality gemstone, expect your jewelry payout to be based on the weight and purity of the precious metal.
\n\n
Step 3: Special Cases—Dental Gold and Coins
\n
\n
Dental gold: Typically ranges from 16K to 22K. It often contains porcelain or steel parts that should be separated when practical. Handle carefully and keep small pieces together in a labeled bag.
\n
Gold and silver coins: Value depends on both metal content and collectible demand. For melt-value purposes, coins are weighed and valued by their gold or silver percentage.
\n
\n\n
Step 4: Weighing and Calculating Value
\n
Once stones are set aside (or simply ignored for value purposes), focus on your metal weight:
\n
\n
Use a digital pocket scale that measures grams accurately. Precious metals are typically valued in grams or troy ounces (31.1 grams per troy ounce).
\n
Separate by purity: Group 10K items apart from 14K items, and silver items apart from gold.
\n
Melt value vs. resale offer: Melt value is based on gold/silver market prices multiplied by purity and weight, but actual offers are lower to cover refining, testing, and overhead.
\n
\n
You can check live pricing benchmarks using reliable financial news outlets or the NIST resources on weights and measures for proper conversions.
\n\n
Step 5: Preparing Jewelry for Mailing or Appraisal
\n
\n
Remove obvious non-metal parts when safely possible (e.g., beads, cords, leather straps).
\n
Keep small pieces together in small labeled bags or envelopes to prevent loss.
\n
Label lots clearly (e.g., “10K gold,” “sterling scrap”) to streamline processing.
\n
Pack securely using bubble wrap or padded envelopes, and place inside a sturdy shipping box.
\n
Choose insured shipping: For higher values, the safest option is USPS Registered Mail. Read about USPS Registered Mail insurance and coverage directly from the postal service.
\n
\n\n
Step 6: The Testing Process Explained
\n
When your items arrive at a buying service or refinery, they usually undergo several standardized tests to confirm purity:
\n
\n
Visual inspection of hallmarks, stamps, and design.
\n
Magnet test to detect non-precious alloys.
\n
Acid spot testing on a small scratch sample to gauge karat level.
\n
Electronic analysis for quick, non-destructive reads.
\n
Weight verification on calibrated scales.
\n
\n
Expect clear testing documentation that explains how the result relates to payout.
\n\n
Step 7: Payment Options and What to Expect
\n
Once your items are valued, you’ll receive payment. Options usually include:
\n\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n
Payment Method | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
PayPal | Fast, widely accepted, easy for online users | May charge small fees depending on account type |
Venmo | Quick transfer, user-friendly | Often app-only, transaction limits |
Zelle | Direct to bank account, no fee in most cases | Bank must support Zelle |
Cash App | Fast and simple | Limits, fees for instant transfer |
ACH Bank Transfer | Secure, direct to bank | 1-3 days typical processing time |
Check | Paper record, safe for large payments | Takes longer to arrive and clear |
\n\n
Step 8: Keep Good Records
\n
Before sending, safeguard yourself with simple documentation:
\n
\n
Take clear photos of items and groupings.
\n
Note weights and stamps in a notebook or digital file.
\n
Keep copies of shipping receipts and insurance documentation.
\n
Optional digital tracking using straightforward tools like GavelBase to store notes, descriptions, and photos together in one place.
\n
\n\n
Quick FAQ
\n
\n Do stones add to the melt value?\n
No. Except for rare, high-quality gemstones, stones generally do not affect melt value.
\n\n Should I remove stones before selling?\n
If you want to keep or reuse stones, remove them before sending. Buyers may not return small stones removed during processing.
\n\n What if I have a valuable gemstone?\n
Seek a gemologist’s appraisal separately. A precious metal buyer focuses on metal content.
\n\n Are small diamonds worth anything?\n
Small diamonds (called melee) have